|
|
 - The End of D&DI will not send 1 dime on 4th ed. It is not a ROLL playing system, but a computer transition. Hasbro can take it and take a flying leap (the godless fatherless get(bastards)). Do not be seduced by the darkside. Rating:  - 4th editionGood bookset. Combination of the well-known 2nd edition and 3rd edition. The good old XP system is back. The d20 roll is simplified and used as core throughout the encounters. Rating:  - SOME THINGS ARE BETTER LEFT UNCHANGED!Dungeons and Dragons 4.0 should, in theory, introduce new concepts and ideas that augment already existing rules and make them better. Regretfully, though, it starts gutting established Dungeons and Dragons rules and procedures that have been in existence for decades. Certain alignments are done away with, certain character classes are let out to pasture, the whole thing comes across as change for the simple sake of change. The 3.5 version was a lot better. Some things are better left unchanged!!! Rating: - BeautifulHi, I'm 37, been roleplaying for years. Introduced to RPG with Runequest (Chaosium) long time ago, later moved on to Call of Cthulhu and AD&D, it was 1989. In 1991 high school moved me out of the RPG tables. In late 90s I heard news about the new edition of D&D, the famous 3.0 (3.5 later) and months later I started buying the core books (DM guide and Players guide) but...this is not the AD&D I was used to play with!!! Dozens of confusing rules, dozens of updates and a extreme slow playing because it was too rule dependent...I spent more time consulting tables than playing...weeks later I quit and sold my core books on Ebay and went back to AD&D (and Runequest sometimes). Since today, I've just received the D&D 4th edition gift set...all I can say is WOW!!! What a big improvement this edition is. What a BEAUTIFUL job Wizards has done! to me this is the best D&D edition ever. Love the design, love the art, everything looks clear and easy to understand and you almost can play it right out of the box, I'm very excited about the new rules (probably because I've never really liked D&D 3.5) because this edition looks more like the classic AD&D I was used to play with. I'm starting tonight with H1-Keep on the Shadowfell...I'll send a report soon. Rating: - No longer Dungeons & DragonsI have been playing incarnations of this game for ove 20 years. I can honestly say that I have had the pleasure of playing each edition including the original boxed sets that came out before the "Advanced" series. Having done so I can report that the current 4th Edition is the worst system yet developed for the game. Where 3rd Edition took many aspects of 1st and 2nd Edition into consideration and re-imagined some of the rules for more interesting game play and better character development, this edition does the opposite. It ingnored the fundamentals of the game (Role Playing, Story Line, and Imagination) and gave us a stripped down version of what a computer game like Warcraft or Everquest might feel like if it was simplified for table top playing. The Character classes now have defensive and offensive roles as if this were a simple strategy game or computer simulation. I cant believe that the writers, editors, and designers agreed to butcher the concept of D&D in order to try and tap into the computer game market. The people at Wizards should hire some new (or re-hire the old ones they got rid of) Research and Development staff to re-discover what made this life long Roleplaying legacy so worth playing and interesting for the millions of D&D fans out there. Have they realized how many people they have put off of roleplaying by this debacle? I'm not sure they will recover from this as I have gone around many local hobby shops and stayed in touch with many of my friends around the US and from what I understand many bought the books and just threw them away. Wizards might report big gains but they will not be able to sustain this game for as long as they did 3rd Edition which is not my favorite but I am willing to admit was a good overhaul of the system with better rules, artwork, and larger emphasis on role playing than this attempt. Dont waste your money. Seriously if you are new to Dungeons and Dragons and want a good system to play I recommend looking for the original 1st Edition books or go sraight to the 3rd Edition. Pass this one over.
|
